Wayne Barrow: BSL vs SSE – The Big Debate

Posted on May 18, 2018 by



For those of you who don’t know me, let me introduce myself before I give you my honest opinions.

My name is Wayne Barrow, and I am a CODA (Child of Deaf Adults). I have spent the last few years of my life campaigning for BSL to be added into the National Curriculum, and with the support of many people and organisations, we managed to have the debate taken into Parliament.

Unfortunately, Nick Gibb, the Minister for the Department for Education, didn’t agree to this (I’m trying not to get angry at him whilst writing this), but we are closer than ever to having BSL taught in schools.

Anyway, now you know a little about me and my background, there is quite a big topical debate within the BSL community, and that is which is better, BSL or SSE? (British Sign Language or Signed Supported English – for those of you who are unsure, I’ve added a brief explanation at the bottom of this article)

I know there are so many different opinions on this debate, so I thought it would be a great chance for me to express my view.

I tend to lean towards SSE when doing my signed song videos and teach signed songs (I have my own company teaching signed songs). My reasoning behind this is because I am from a performing background, so I think it’s really important to try and stay as close to the artist’s lyrics that they have written.

They have created a piece of art, and for me to portray that art for someone who may not be able to hear it, I would rather they see it in the way it was written. Now, that’s not to say that those who use BSL in music are wrong, I completely celebrate them and think that it is fantastic to use both. You need to remember this is personal preference.

There has always been a huge debate within the deaf and hard of hearing community about BSL and SSE, I do think it is important to keep BSL alive, as it is something we should be proud of. It’s a beautiful language, with a wonderful, visual structure. I absolutely adore it.

But you have to remember, BSL isn’t for everyone. Some people prefer to use SSE, and that’s the big split in the deaf and hard of hearing community. I often come across comments towards my videos telling me how awful I am because I use SSE when I sign my songs, but I can imagine in the same breath, people who use BSL structure in songs will probably get abuse for not translating the song the way it was written.

We, as a society, have to recognise that every person is different, we all have different ways of communicating, whether you speak English, French, Spanish and so on. I do not use the same English when speaking to my friends as I do when I’m on the phone, and this goes with when I’m using BSL and SSE too.

Some people I use SSE with, and others BSL. We are all individual, and we all have our own techniques to deal with certain situations, and I think we should all celebrate one another for being able to express our own emotions in such a beautiful way.

I know what some of you are thinking now “there are ‘BSL Tutors’ who are teaching SSE, and giving people the wrong impression”, and yes, I am completely on your side for this argument.

I run my own academy teaching signing songs, and every new member who joins us will always be told that we are using SSE, and we give an explanation as to what the difference is between the two.

However, I have seen Tutors who claim to teach BSL and are actually teaching SSE, this is something that needs to be stopped and these Tutors need to explain what they are actually teaching.

We need to make sure that when people are learning any form of sign, they are educated correctly and properly, so they can make an informed choice as to what they are actually learning. However, that being said, I would much rather see someone using broken SSE/BSL and making the effort to learn, than know nothing at all.

At the end of the day, we need to be bringing more people together, and break down any communication barriers, we just have to make sure we do it the right way, and make sure that people are informed about what they are in fact learning.

Brief explanation of BSL & SSE:

BSL – stands for British Sign Language. This has it’s own sentence structure that is unlike the English spoken language. (E.g. your name what?)

SSE – stands for Signed Supported English. This is using signs from BSL, however reordering the sentences to be the same as the English spoken language. (E.g. what’s your name?)

Wayne Barrow is a TV & Radio Presenter who has grown up with deaf parents. His passion for music and signing have combined together to create another visual aspect to music by signing along to songs. He has used this as a tool to help promote his campaign to get BSL taught in schools.

 


Enjoying our eggs? Support The Limping Chicken:



The Limping Chicken is the world's most popular Deaf blog, and is edited by Deaf  journalist,  screenwriter and director Charlie Swinbourne.

Our posts represent the opinions of blog authors, they do not represent the site's views or those of the site's editor. Posting a blog does not imply agreement with a blog's content. Read our disclaimer here and read our privacy policy here.

Find out how to write for us by clicking here, and how to follow us by clicking here.

The site exists thanks to our supporters. Check them out below:

Posted in: wayne barrow