Do deaf people sleep more peacefully than hearing folk? This question occurred to me when we were buying our house last year.
Our house is next to a main road, but since my wife and I are deaf, we had no worries over the prospect of being disturbed by traffic noise. We just wouldn’t hear it. So we went ahead and bought the house.
Meanwhile, a (non-deaf) friend who lives up the road told me that when they were looking for a house, he and his wife never looked at any houses on main roads because he’s so sensitive to sound at night.
He would literally wake up if he heard any sound at all, whether it was a bird cheeping in the morning or a car door being shut down the road. For him, buying a house by a road meant he might face years of disturbed sleep.
I’ve also long known that being married to someone who is also deaf also means I’ve got away with being a chronic snorer.
I’ve always snored – I remember hearing friends complaining about it when I stayed over at their houses when I was a child. Yet my wife sleeps soundly, no matter how loudly my nasal passages vibrate. I guess this is a whole other question: would I be happily married if my wife was hearing? Discuss…
Of course being disturbed by sound isn’t the only reason people have trouble sleeping. Stress, medication, depression or jet lag can give people insomnia, whether you’re deaf or not. But I’d guess that being able to hear makes sleeping well much harder if you suffer from any of the above (or are lucky enough to have been abroad).
I doubt whether I could sleep soundly if I was suddenly able to hear. I’ve always slept without hearing aids on, but once or twice, as a student, I accidentally went to sleep with them still on (I confess, I’d had a few drinks) and found I had disturbed nights filled with vivid, unsettling dreams – influenced by the fact that I could hear sounds (including my own snoring!) while I was asleep.
I’m so used to sleeping in relative silence that curiously, relatively minor sounds can wake me up. A few weeks ago, a smoke alarm in our bedroom made a bleeping sound at night, because its battery had gone flat. I didn’t know what the sound was, but I could hear the beep (which occurred every minute or so) faintly and eventually I woke up, felt a bit confused for a while, then, after putting my hearing aids on, found out what it was.
When I mentioned this article to our Deputy Editor, Andy Palmer, he mentioned two things in relation to deafness and sleeping.
First, that his deaf son sleeps soundly even if Andy’s got people round at his house and music is on loudly. Second, he mentioned that his deaf mother can’t hear Andy’s dad snoring – but that she does get disturbed by the vibrations (!).
So deafness helps us deaf folk sleep – but hearing insomniacs who might be considering crossing over to the deaf side, be warned: it doesn’t solve everything.
So, do you think that since we can’t hear so much, deaf people sleep more soundly than hearing folk, or not? Tell us in the comments below!
By Charlie Swinbourne. Charlie is the editor of Limping Chicken, as well as being a journalist and award-winning scriptwriter. He broke the ‘fake’ interpreter story on this site, and writes for the Guardian and BBC Online. As a scriptwriter, he penned the films My Song, Departure Lounge and Coming Out, and has just written and directed short film The Kiss and the half-hour comedy Four Deaf Yorkshiremen go to Blackpool(which is out on the BSL Zone on the 19th May).
Sam
May 8, 2014
I certainly can’t sleep with my CI/HA in and I love not hearing anything at night, BUT it means that the shock of the vibrating alarm when Abby shouts in the night is quite something!!! Also, I find that I am quite sensitive to light and have to make the room as dark as possible, I end up being an early riser in the summer and serial snooze-button user in the winter!!
Helen
May 8, 2014
Deaf people’s sleep can be badly disturbed by a couple of things: light seeping into the room if light is swtiched on by accident and a bedmate moving around in the bed. Oh one more, the cat at 5am for its breakfast!
Lana
May 8, 2014
Helen, oh poor you, at 5am by your cat – my dog forces me to get up no later than 9am sharp
Hartmut
May 11, 2014
Oh my, your cat found its milk on you!
Barakta
May 8, 2014
Brilliant post for a morning!
I’ve had people vacuuming under my bed while I was asleep for the lolz – I didn’t wake up either time. A vacuum cleaner is usually making about 80dB of noise and our one is especially evil and loud (I can’t reliably tell if it’s on or off without hearing aids tho). My ex boyfriend snored shockingly, I couldn’t hear it, his next girlfriend who was hearing completely freaked out on him cos of the noise – that and his 7 alarm clocks going off suddenly one morning to (usually fail to) wake him up which I slept through 😉 I laughed!
I fell asleep in the bath once, bathroom light switch was INSIDE the bathroom. Cue partner and friend flicking the breaker on and off and using the smoke alarm self test as the only noise they could think of that I might hear. I think the light woke me, I could only just hear the smoke alarm outside the bathroom – it was quieter than tinnitus. I have great difficulty convincing hearies that that noise they can’t bear, barely registers for me without my hearing aid, which I like, I like the peace!
I am sensitive to vibration though, once stayed in a travel lodge near a motorway and the whole place shook constantly. I couldn’t sleep through the vibration which my hearing partner could barely notice.
Flashing lights don’t wake me up well, they make me hallucinate in a half asleep state. I banned them from the bedroom except for the now deaf-accessible fire alarm unit we have which also has a vibrator. Otherwise it’s vibrating alarm clocks all the way (yes yes I know vibrator hee hee to the members of the public at the back there chortling away). Partners do have to be tolerant of the alarm clocks which are pure evil.
John David Walker
May 8, 2014
My partner gets infuriated about how quickly I go to sleep at night. Lights off, head touches the pillow and I’m gone (well, most of the time). My hearing partner has to spend hours winding down. Is it just me or is this common amongst deaf dreamers?
Chloe
May 8, 2014
Lol I can definitely sleep so well most nights! Like you said your post, people can’t sleep if they are stressed, medication etc. can be hard to make people sleep. I definitely can’t sleep if there is something bothering me.
Sometimes when I’m asleep and it’s raining, I don’t even hear the rain/thunder and my family complain about not having a good night’s sleep (my family are hearing) and I say to my family. “What? It was raining and there were thunders last night?” I didn’t even know that until they told me and when I have a peek outside. It makes me glad sometimes. But sometimes I can sleep in and miss out on my alarm, so there are pros and cons 🙂
Ursula Hulme
May 8, 2014
I used to sleep with my hearing aid on when the children were babies and certainly slept a lot less – just couldn’t trust the vibrating alarms! I have had a few hospital stays over the years and nurses are always bemused of the fact that I can sleep through the constant bustle of hospital night life.
Cathy
May 8, 2014
An interesting question is posed here! I think it would depend on the degree of deafness that would make it a case of: can sleep or can’t sleep.
As Iam profoundly deaf I can sleep through a thunderstorm without so much as stirring! However, I suffer from chronic tinnitus, so getting to sleep is a massive problem!
Once I have managed to nod off Iam fine and being a deep sleeper, I suppose, helps.
Hearing friends sometimes complain and ask me: “Did u hear that thunderstorm last night?” I reply: “what thunderstorm?” I haven’t a clue! They envy me the fact I can sleep through anything, so if a hearing man has problems with a hearing wife because he’s a dreadful snorer, get divorced and marry me, you’ll be fine for the rest of your sleeping life!!!
donaldo of the wasatch
May 8, 2014
Yeah, light bothers me. The most amazing experience was waking up at 1AM in the morning with the fire department shining a flashlight in my face – the unit diagonally from me had a fire. They busted in my door that did not get repaired by management for 3 months. But, hey otherwise I sleep well, except for the nightmares that I experience that is akin to the PSTD stuff. That is another story that deals with bigotry.
elisabethphysio
May 8, 2014
Interesting as a hearing friend of mine believes that deaf people get a better night’s sleep than hearing people, but as Charlie says in his article, it is not just sleeping in a “golden silence” that ensures a good sleep; deaf people are thought to suffer more mental health problems due to isolation, loneliness and this can perhaps manifest in disturbed sleep patterns. Equally, I am easily disturnbed by someone switching the light on; I’m instantly awake, and also any vibration or sudden unexpected movement. When I was younger, no-one explained to me that my grandmother would be sharing the bed with me one night – I come from a large Irish family where squeezing in at big family events was quite the norm – but it didn’t prepare me for one of the shocks of my life, thinking there was a monster in my bed and causing me to leap across the room in fright! That I still remember that to this day shows how powerful the effect of being unexpectedly being woken in your sleep can be! One thing that bother me is this: the number of hearing people that complain about their partner snoring….why is nothing done about the snoring????
Vicky
May 8, 2014
My deaf son shared a room with his brother when he was a baby and was never once woken up by him. He always seems to sleep well
Richard... theman@thebackofthegarage
May 8, 2014
I’m rapidly going deaf, with no hearing in my right ear and little in my left and hadn’t really thought about this conundrum until now. Guess what, I dream with sound! So when I’m asleep, I hear….. in a strange sort of way! :-/ but not really! 60 years of sound has left a lasting memory. I suppose this would be different for people who have been Deaf from a pre-linguistic time!?
As for snoring, it’s not the noise that’s the problem, it’s the vacuum caused when she snores! It sucks the pillow from under my head! 🙁
Squeaky
May 8, 2014
Being Deaf and asleep does bring its own issues. One night my pals and I were sleeping on deck on a boat in the middle of the ocean… when dawn broke, my friends were awoken by the sound of dolphins swimming. By the time my pals had shaken me awake; the dolphins had swum away and I had missed out on what was evidently a very quick and magical moment! Anyone know of a Wi-Fi alerter that works in the middle of the sea to the sounds of dolphins clicking/whistling..???!!!
Ian
May 8, 2014
I think you will find not all deaf people sleep well at night. Interesting, the author is able to hear the smoke alarm without aids….just. I can’t hear anything without hearing aids.
I accept for many, that lack of hearing anything helps them sleep. I have a different problem though, for many years I found I was a very aggressive person, I would change at the smallest of things into a not-so-nice type. I saw lots of other negative traits such as being grumpy, lack of concentration, impatient, always tired. I also believed I had a lovely long sleep at night and some days could be hard to wake in the morning. As a child, nightmares were common as was deciding to crawl into my parents bed. In my thirties I finally worked out what was causing this. I found I was waking up every fifteen minutes or so as I was scared I would not hear if the smoke alarm went off, an intruder broke in, the alarm clock or my work trying to contact me. I was not aware of waking up but this was enough for me to not go into a deep sleep…..causing the symptoms and many more that I’ve already described. I have since met many other deaf people that have the same issue or have the symptoms without realising they have the issue.
Now I have identified this and have a solution that gives me the confidence I won’t have these fears, I have found I get the best of both worlds….I can’t hear anything to disturb my sleep but will wake up if there is a sound I need to know about.
Peter
May 8, 2014
I snore terribly and ALL my exes (hearing ones) have complained of it. I don’t wear aids or CI at night but bizzarely I can hear in my dreams.
I’m also extremely difficult to wake up.
Janel
May 8, 2014
I am profoundly deaf, a light sleeper, and super sensitive to vibration. I sometimes have a hard time falling asleep because I can hear low-frequency/high-dB sounds and strong vibrations like trains, loud cars and trucks, even snoring, thunder, etc. Once I fall asleep and it is quiet, these things do not usually wake me up. But if I wake up, and there’s noise/vibration, I can’t return to sleep. I HAVE been woken up by heavy trains, thunder, and gunshots though. I once went through two months of insomnia until I figured out it was the AC unit running outside my bedroom window that was keeping me awake! I moved to a different bedroom.
Emma
May 8, 2014
I’m a CI/HA wearer too, but take them off at night (hey we need a break sometimes). Mostly I’m out for the count as soon as i hit the pillow, but most recently it has been blinking tinnitus which wakes me up – which can only be pacified by putting my CI on (weird). I’m also woken by light, or my trusty shakey alarm clock!
Ged
May 9, 2014
Please don’t be offended by my next statement I am a hearing adult who’s wife is also a hearing adult……..your article is particularly poigniant as my wife snores very loudly but has done so for 20 yrs……believe me when I say I wish I was deaf at night and hearing through the day……I have worn foam inserts in my ears at night for near 20 yrs and I can even hear her through them……..right now I’m lay in the spare room, just so I may get some sleep and I’m not usually a light sleeper but I feel my wife’s snoring is getting worse and my sleep pattern is, at best disturbed and at times nonexistent……..so to answer your question just about everyone sleeps better than me, no matter how hearing or deaf they may or not be
Oh Dear
May 9, 2014
‘Our house is next to a main road, but since my wife and I are deaf, we had no worries over the prospect of being disturbed by traffic noise. We just wouldn’t hear it. So we went ahead and bought the house.’
Did you ever consider the resale value of the house in the future?
Did you ever consider how easy/hard it will be to sale the house?
Editor
May 9, 2014
Haha good point! Guess we might be here for a while then!
Hartmut
May 11, 2014
The house will be resold to Deaf buyers. It will remain a Deaf House forever, I hope.
Rachel
May 9, 2014
I used to be jealous of my hearing brother being woken up by thunderstorms as I missed all the excitement of lighting, the colours and the clouds. He used to be jealous of me sleeping through! Suppose can’t win! 🙂
George Luke
May 9, 2014
This great but works only when someone is deaf…you cant even hear your snoring.
Hartmut
May 12, 2014
My family along with 3 Millions of Sudeten-Germans were being expelled from our homes. We transported on open cattle cars. Only I slept soundly. The rhythm of the cho-cho kept me sleepy, while it was disturbing everyone in the train. Only when the train was braking, generating screeching vibration, I woke up. This surprised my folks, thinking I was suddenly cured of deafness.
Another incident, later I woke up in the middle of the night and woke up my brothers, reporting to have “heard” a unusual hum of low frequency. My brothers thought I was hallucinating.
I usually would continue sleeping, even when I felt people’s steps walking into my bedroom, felt air whooshing into the room, as long as I could identify what they were. I could sleep with the light on, but if the room is dark, I would wake up when a light flashes or passes me, as if coming from a flashlight. A moving light around me would be a signal, to me, to which I must wake up to find out what happens.
Deafnotdaft
May 12, 2014
Thanks for sharing your story, Hartmut. The last paragraph makes it sound as though your “subconscious self” could interpret what was going on while your “conscious self” was asleep. I’ve heard of this before with deaf people. The brain seems to be capable of the strangest things as it compensates for hearing loss!
Olivia Clark
June 7, 2014
I never though of this question before but it got me thinking and interested to know the answer. Thank you for sharing the answer with us I think that the best person to answer this question is someone deaf like you. I envy you for that matter because I’m also very sensitive to noise when I sleep the slightest noise can wake me up and I wouldn’t be able to get back to sleep.You can consider yourself lucky again because a lot of women hate it when their man snores so I’m pretty sure you and your wife would have a more harmonious marriage compared to other couples. I wish the both of you all the best!
George Luke
June 9, 2014
Hi Charlie this is great, i have never seen my roommate who had hearing problem never woke up at night what ever happen even at night i find it difficult to wake him up each time i gotta get to him