Signsong tends to spark a love it/hate it response from the Deaf community. However as a performer and tutor of signsong I can see for myself how interest in the art form is surely growing.
But when I tell people what it is I do, I still get the occasional screwed up face and an exclamation of:
“But you’re deaf! Music isn’t for deaf people!”
Cue exasperated sigh. Because here is where they have the most common misconception.
Its. Not. About. The. Music.
If sign song was all about our ability to hear then yes, I would put my hands up and get myself another job. But it’s not. Baffled? Let me explain.
I’ve always believed that signsingers are in effect very skilled story tellers. When you look at a song you are basically looking at a story. The lyrics, of course, are the words to this tale.
The melody of the lyrics portray the unique style in which the tale is being expressed. This can involve emphasising certain words or phrases, and even the clever use of pauses for dramatic effect.
Rebecca signing Crash and Burn by Savage Garden
The musical setting – the tone, pace, composition of notes – all works to set and support the mood of the story. Drum breaks and crescendos can amplify powerful feelings whereas softer instrumentals depict a sorrowful sentiment.
You may wonder how this is possible if you can’t actually hear the music and therefore can’t pick up the style, the mood or the tale of a story. And this is where those signsinging sceptics are partly right. Because I would never choose to perform a song that I could not follow.
A lot of the songs I use have strong bass lines, powerful beats and easily identifiable rhythms. Without giving my performance secrets away too much, it’s mostly memory and guess work that keeps me in time with the music. That and my trusty communicator, Lady Liz, who dutifully acts as my visual metronome throughout the song and cues my song starts.
There have been times where my hearing aid has cut off mid performance and I’ve had to rely on the visual beat I could see in the form of Liz’s hand tapping and my own memory of the song’s rhythm to keep me in time. Maybe it’s my years as a dancer that has given me the ability to remember rhythms physically, but I do think it’s a skill that can be developed.
Funnily enough, I’ve met plenty of hearing people who are tone deaf and as musical as a plank of wood… And yet there are Deaf people who naturally have rhythm in their soul. They may be aware of this gift from a young age, depending on their exposure to music and its accessibility. Other times it takes a while before they discover this form of expression.
Countless times in my sign song workshops I’ve met children and adults who have, in their words, called themselves ‘Proper Deaf.’ These are strong BSL users who most definitely do not want to associate themselves with music.
But throughout the course of the workshop they find they’ve learnt a brand new way of expressing themselves. A way that takes their native language and paints a visual picture, supported by a rhythmical frame of beats and pauses.
Some participants have even been moved to tears, overjoyed that they are now able to access the lyrics of the great songwriters and fully share their meaning. There are phrases in songs that can depict a powerful sentiment in a simple sentence and made even more beautiful by using sign language.
I believe the role of a signsinger is to tell the story as visually and honestly as possible. We are not merely ‘interpreting the music’ or ‘translating the words.’ Instead we embody the song and become living personifications for the story that is being told. We become the tale.
By breaking down the rhythmical components of the song and ultimately communicating the ‘story,’ sign singing is most definitely an art form that all children and adults can participate in – regardless of their ability to physically hear.
We all have a story to tell. And sign singing is just one way of expressing it.
Rebecca-Anne Withey is an actress, sign singer and tutor of performing arts. A black country girl at heart, she now resides in Derby where she works in both performance art and holistic therapies. She writes on varied topics close to her heart in the hope that they may serve to inspire others.
Ruth
June 10, 2014
Beautifully written. I hope join in your workshop one day.
Linda Richards
June 10, 2014
Enjoyed reading this.
Signsong is an art form if done well. Two things enhance the success of this. Having the correct lyrics to begin with and understanding that the signs that are used may not be linguistically correct or appropriate. In both cases, the wrong meaning can be given.
To illustrate the former, someone signed Madonna’s ‘Papa, don’t preach’. The performance hinged around understanding the lyrics to be “get rid of him” (the boyfriend) and not “get rid of it” (the unborn baby). The latter was correct. The former wasn’t but by choosing to focus the whole signsong on getting rid of the boyfriend (and not the baby), the real ‘message’ of the song was lost. (After all, why would papa ‘preach’ if she was just going out with a boyfriend???). However well this signsong was done, with clear signs and rhythm, it jarred because it was the wrong set of lyrics – actually, it was the one word that was wrong and which threw it all out of kilter.
To illustrate the issue of choice of signs, as seen in a number of TV programmes and in some signsongs, the use of the sign ‘when?’ – a question – doesn’t (I feel) give the correct sense of timeline or perspective. So a piece of dialogue that starts “When you go to …” Or a song that starts “When I fall in love…” shouldn’t be signed with the BSL sign for the question ‘When?’
It’s a balance between signed lyrics or signed meaning. There are generally two camps – those who want a signed English version so they have ‘access’ to the lyrics and those who clamour for the BSL version so they have ‘access’ to the meaning.
Your article shows this art form is what people can do and how they can take it further. That’s what art is about. Taking something and developing it or adding another angle – such as the rhythm you mention.
I also personally believe that BSL is richer, clearer and more expressive than say, ASL in signsong.
I’m still hoping to see Simon and Garfunkel’s ‘Bridge over troubled water’ and Don McLean’s ‘American pie’ translated in a way that gives both the rhythm and meaning but above all the intensity of the lyrics and the pictures they conjure in the mind. I’ve looked at these over the years and see how life experiences or world knowledge changes or influences this also.
Would be fascinating to review this as time goes by and to see if we change our signsongs be it style or content.
Best wishes for your workshops.
garry withey
June 11, 2014
What a wonderful girl rebecca is!!! I am totally in support of her love of things that would not initially be of interest to a deaf person that she is and her determination to prove both hearing and deaf people wrong in their belief that music us only for the hearing.i have a slight confession though, becky is my daughter and has been surprising us from the dsy she was born.
Editor
June 11, 2014
Aha! Well I’m sure it’s not only her family members who think highly of her! Ed.
Julie P
June 12, 2014
Absolutely lovely post!
I am so eager to get more deaf/hard of hearing people involved within media and sing-signing world.
It really is a beautiful way of expressing yourself with emotions, exploring different culterally rich BSL signs but to involve other people in the songs too.
I really don’t think it’s anything to do with the melody/song itself, it’s merely there just to help hearing. I enjoy doing but also watching people performing song-signing on youtube etc.
Thank you for your post Rebecca and continue the great work!
JP.