Holidays. You work yourself to the bone (or merely to the beak in the Chicken’s case) all year round and your reward is two weeks away from home when you get to relax, unwind, switch off, and enjoy yourself.
I’ve just come back from two weeks in Scotland and don’t get me wrong, I had an amazing time with my wife and kids exploring the west coast and Scotland’s spectacular lochs and islands – not to mention a day at the Edinburgh Fringe where we saw a BSL debate (keep an eye out for my review of the show later this week).
But however breathtaking the scenery was (and I recommend visiting the Isle of Mull as soon as you possibly can) I was also reminded about how, when you’re deaf, you can find some things on holiday plain annoying.
Some of these are specific to our own experience, while others could apply to anywhere you go on holiday.
Here they are…
1) Boat trips without access to the commentary
We took a trip around Loch Lomond which played an audio commentary about the loch and its sights which had been recorded by a BBC presenter.
The boat offered printed transcripts in French, German and a number of other languages, except – crucially – in English. They’d run out, apparently.
So we went round the loch for an hour without a clue what we were looking at. Which isn’t much fun.
We then met the owner of the company, who responded to our complaint about the lack of transcript via the twin mediums of anger and provocation.
Which was even less fun.
2) Slow wi-fi or 3G connections
No-one goes on holiday to spend all their time online – and I’m not suggesting anyone rips up the Scottish Highlands to lay some fibre cable anytime soon.
But for deaf people, slow or non-existent mobile internet connections in remote areas make it impossible to use some of the online services you’re used to using day in, day out at home – like FaceTime or Skype if you’re signing (or lipreading), WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter or more simply, email.
I won’t deny that there’s something relaxing about being offline – until you’re trying to book a ferry trip and the page won’t load.
3) Trying to lipread foreign accents
I should start by saying Scotland’s not a foreign country (although it could be in a just a month’s time if they vote for independence).
But wherever you’re from, trying to lipread people who speak in a very different accent from your own can be tricky (it’s just as hard, I’d imagine, for a deaf Scot coming to England).
After a while, I thought I should get a t-shirt printed that said “sorry, could you repeat that?” So that I could save myself the bother of actually saying it.
Happily, most Scots were lovely (kudos to the two volunteers at the Oban War and Peace Museum) and more than happy to repeat themselves.
The first three times I couldn’t make out what they were saying, at least.
4) No subtitles on the hotel TV
Just like with wi-fi, no-one goes on holiday to spend all their time watching TV. Honest.
But when you’ve got kids, and you’ve been out all day, and you’ve just battled to put them to bed for the best part of an hour, the telly is a medium by which you can escape the pure madness of parenthood.
By watching the Commonwealth Games (which were happening just down the road) or the Scottish Independence Debate, for example.
But for some reason, the TV at the lodge we stayed in for the first week was connected to a hotel TV system which didn’t allow subtitles to be shown on TV channels at all.
This had its compensations – it meant we reminded ourselves just how good Seinfeld is (if you’ve never seen it, here’s a subtitled clip) by working our way through the box set of series 7.
But it was annoying, and ultimately, this shouldn’t still be happening in 2014.
5) Finding yourself unable to do much other than eat and drink while away
The fact is that accessible theatre performances (via captioning or sign interpretation) and subtitled cinema screenings are nearly always available only in large cities and towns (even then, you have to research the times carefully).
So when you’re anywhere more remote, what you gain in greenery and beautiful surroundings you lose in, er, entertainment options (that might be the most boring possible way of describing something that’s supposed to excite you, but there goes).
When you’re deaf and on holiday, you tend to find that when it comes to evening entertainment, you’re limited, in the main, to spending time in the local pubs or restaurants.
I like my food and drink and chatter, so that’s not the end of the world, but it’d be nice to be able access more local culture while away.
I don’t know what the solution to this problem is, but I do know that my waistline would be grateful if one could be found.
Automatic iPad transcription, anyone?
Do you have any examples of things you’ve found annoying on holiday? Tell us below.
Charlie Swinbourne is the editor of Limping Chicken, as well as being a journalist (Guardian, BBC Online) and award-winning scriptwriter. His short film The Kiss was shown at Bradford International Film Festival in March, and his comedy Four Deaf Yorkshiremen go to Blackpool can now be seen on the BSL Zone by clicking here.
The Limping Chicken is the world’s 6th most popular disability blog. Make sure you never miss a post by finding out how to follow us, and don’t forget to check out what our supporters provide:
- Phonak: innovative technology and products in hearing acoustics
- Bellman: hearing loss solutions
- Ai-Live: Live captions and transcripts
- Deaf Umbrella: sign language interpreting and communications support
- Sign Video: Instant sign language support online
- 121 Captions: captioning and speech-to-text services
- Doncaster School for the Deaf: education for Deaf children
- Signworld: online BSL learning and teaching materials
Cathy Alexandeŕ
August 19, 2014
This is great Charlie, but as I have been deaf virtually all my life, none of what you have said comes as a surprise to me.
Deaf people in real terms are only living half a life, mainly doing the same things over n over again, such as deaf clubs, pub nights, bingo and deaf holidays!
So, it is not just on family holidays where problems lie: it is everywhere every single day of our lives! Do we trot off to the cinema each week? Not unless there is a subtitled film we dont. Do we visit the theatre on a regular basis? Only if there are captions or an interpreter, if not, we wont be attending. Even then not all deaf people enjoy interpreted shows: sat in semi darkness with a fair distance from them and the terp, trying to follow the show with so many different characters and trying to keep up with who is speaking to who? It is not as easy as many may think and I recall watching a pantomime where I could hear hearing people laughing, but the deaf ones were not. Were we following it all exactly? Doubtful.
It would be good to join a book club, provided you could read, but who would pay the interpreter or lipspeaker? Nobody. We could pay ourselves but interpreters rates are far too high to make it a regular hobby!
Do you see deaf people at festivals? Rarely or never as we cant access music or blinding tinnitus means such events are a no no.
Would we get access to shows like: Dancing On Ice? No we dont as managers refuse to provide interpreters saying it is not logistical!
Even short breaks away in hotels or BnB’s still have TV’s with no subtitles! In 2014 that is amazing! In 1 hotel in London I sent a letter to ask for half my money back because I had no access to the TV, they duly obliged! But should they not be solving the problem? Of course they should but they never do!!
It would be nice to join a knitting circle, but how, when ones hands are needed for signing, so you cant knit at the same time! Besides most people are hearing in these circles, so how would we follow? The answer is we can’t. Not all deaf people can lipread and not all hearing people can be lipred.
I would love to join a ghost hunt, but how can we follow conversation in dark unlit rooms? Even an interpreter would be difficult to follow……..
And what fun it would be to be hypnotised! But that is impossible, when you need to be awake to communicate!
Am sure you will agree and get my drift, Charlie, deaf people are not living truly full lives, even if they may think they are!
Sandra Dowe
August 19, 2014
This description of experiences should go to everyone involved in organising holiday trips.