I’m deaf. I lip read and I find some signs help me. Can you help?
A regular request for lipspeakers and a growing method of communication support. But what is it? Where does it fit? Is there a qualification?
Well you certainly won’t find anything that resembles this on the Signature website. There is no professional qualification. It is known as Lipspeaking with Signed Support. (LSS)
The issue facing Lipspeakers and deaf people is the vast difference in the ability of Lipspeakers to deliver effective lipspeaking and signs at the same time.
One could argue that those holding the highest BSL credentials would be the best.However this isn’t always the case. In fact the opposite could be true.
Many Lipspeakers will try too hard to concentrate on which is the correct sign to add, and in context, their mouth patterns, facial expressions and natural gesture weakens. Those with higher BSL skills could start to emulate BSL lip patterns instead, resulting in incorrect lip patterns and confusion.
Confused? Let’s go back to basics.
Lipspeaking in its purest form relies only on mouth pattern, facial expression, natural gesture and if requested, some finger spelling to support words that are difficult to lip read. ( think of lip reading the words Few and View. Much clearer if the lipspeaker adds a F or V respectively and uses her eyes to ‘view’ or facial expression to support the word ‘few’.).
Or say the word Statistic in the mirror without using your voice. Can you lip read it? It’s virtually impossible but with the sign added, it becomes much clearer as the user will understand the word from the sign and not worry about the lip pattern.
Lip reading alone is hard even for the most experienced lip readers. It’s tiring, and only 40-50% of what is said is lip readable.
Statistics are hard to find to support any such claim but it is generally accepted that with a qualified lipspeaker, around 60% of any message is lip readable, yet with LSS some users claim that over 90% is understood.
Very subjective stats I know, but in the absence of any substantive research, one has to reply on the voice of the lip reader.
Many of us lipspeakers are asked to add some signs. Those who can, do so.
We are now having to ask at each booking if the user needs some signs. This is very different from before, when a booking was pure lipspeaking.
More and more Lipspeakers are now learning how to sign to be able to meet this growing demand and many BSL interpreters are now training to be Lipspeakers (the latest lipspeaker level 3 training course has 5 interpreters from the 14 students)
Critics may say you can’t mix sign with lipspeaking. Well you can. I have been doing it successfully for over ten years.
I work freelance, and clients include the British government in many different departments – including the home office, foreign and commonwealth office – as well as the court and police services, health, education and various charities.
I work full time and the demand for LSS is growing. The majority of clients are post lingual deafened people but more and more are cochlear implant users who decide to move away from BSL into English but need to learn to lip read.
A lipspeaker offering sign language support is often appealing once they know it exists.
Lipspeakers pare down the message when the speaker talks quickly. We remove redundant language without changing the meaning. This means we process the message, remove what isn’t necessary, (if someone said
“two twins” for example, the word two would be removed).
This is a skill in itself but to then add a sign, in context, keeping one’s lip patterns lip readable and continue, usually alone for up to two hours is no mean feat.
In 2013 I was honoured to receive the Signature Communication Professional of the Year Award; only the second lipspeaker to receive this accolade so I must be doing something right.
Lesley is one of only two lipspeakers cleared to work in any government department. Her career has seen her work as a nurse and midwife, lipspeaker and notetaker and she is currently training to be a BSL interpreter. Lesley was the Signature regional winner for Learner of the Year in 2012 and the Communication Professional of the Year in 2013. Lesley formed the only specialist Lipspeaking agency, Lipspeaker UK in 2010 after growing demands for her services.
You can book Lipspeakers who can use SSL on www.lipspeaker.co.uk
The Limping Chicken is the UK’s deaf news and opinions website, and is the world’s 6th most popular disability blog.
Make sure you never miss a post by finding out how to follow us, and don’t forget to check out what our supporters provide:
- Phonak: innovative technology and products in hearing acoustics
- Bellman: hearing loss solutions
- Ai-Live: Live captions and transcripts
- Deaf Umbrella: sign language interpreting and communications support
- SignVideo: Instant BSL video interpreting online
- 121 Captions: captioning and speech-to-text services
- Doncaster School for the Deaf: education for Deaf children
- Signworld: online BSL learning and teaching materials
- Exeter Deaf Academy: education for Deaf children
- SignHealth: healthcare charity for Deaf people
- Lipspeaker UK: specialist lipspeaking support
- STAGETEXT: theatre captioning
- CJ Interpreting: communication support in BSL
- SDHH: Deaf television programmes online
- Sign Solutions:, language and learning
- Sign Lingual: BSL interpreting and communication services
- Action Deafness Communications: sign language and Red Dot online video interpreting
- Hamilton Lodge School in Brighton: education for Deaf children
- RAD: financial advice for Deaf people
- cSeeker: Online booking for communication support
- Krazy Kat: visual theatre with BSL
- Enable Support Services: Supporting Deaf children and adults in Suffolk, Essex, Cambridgeshire and Norfolk
- Sign Language Days: Sign language learning in schools
Cathy Alexandeŕ
September 25, 2014
Well well well, those who worry about the decline of BSL and its inevitable death, need no further proof, it is here in all its glory!!!
Those with CI’s move from BSL to English! This is a very interesting concept and means those without CI’s are going to be the new minority especially those without speech.
BSL interpreters who have learnt the language may be surprised that they now need to change tactics and become a lipspeaker! Hopefully they wont feel they have wasted thousands of pounds learning BSL!
What does the future hold here? Is BSL turning into a dying art? Are current deaf children using sign language? As many now have CI’s this is doubtful, which means BSL classes will become defunct, in place of lipspeaking classes, however, this will impact on deaf tutors teaching BSL, if their class closes what will they do next? Teach lipspeaking? Hardly, when they cannot hear this would be pretty difficult.
To this degree many deaf tutors are going to be grappling around in the jobs market looking for work of some kind, given the retirement age is rising!
Iam not sure the deaf community is actually making progress in life, when we think of all the potential problems ahead of us: BSL classes will be dead; DLA about to vanish next year; deaf people still battling to find work in a predominantly hearing world; mental health issues possibly rising as a result and barely any solutions in sight for what is going to, possibly become the most depressed ghetto in Britain!
Lesley Weatherson
September 25, 2014
I understand your concerns about BSL. I am training to be an interpreter and would not be spending thousands of pounds if I believed it would be wasted.
To me It’s about meeting the needs of deaf people.
Cathy Alexandeŕ
September 25, 2014
Yes Lesley, the needs of deaf people should be met, but they are not always so. BSL classes at my local College have already closed, so where will people go to learn?
The cuts, which are inevitable are having a negative affect on deaf people with little realisation amongst Managers and Directors etc of this impact.
Not only that, as the months and years go by you may find you have less and less work as deaf people with CI’s decide to use lipspeakers instead of interpreters, what will you do? Start training to be a lipspeaker and spend all over again?
I have no idea of ur age but you could be working, even part time until you r 70! Not an ideal prospect, perhaps, but simultaneously, technology will have marched right on by then and coupled with Science, this means that deaf people without speech and heavily reliant on BSL will be a rarity!
As we have no idea what the future will actually bring it may b wise to ensure that you have other skills at your disposal.
Natalya
September 25, 2014
That’s really interesting, and brings up various issues about whether BSL interpreters who don’t scale to SSE are actually doing what deaf people need or not as many people seem to range between “pure BSL” and some level of SSE in preference.
I would probably consider lipspeaking more if it was BSL/SSEish rather than just lipspeaking on its own, much like if I do have to use a BSL terp I’d prefer SSEish signing cos my sign’s not that great (am working on it).
I currently use STTR which works well cos I can lipread and glance at STTR screen for visual reinforcement and memory cos I read fast and it gives me a bit of a breathing space so I don’t have to stay on-focus 100% of the time. But it’s not useful currently in a non-static situation or for mingling social conversation arena.
Richard Turner
September 25, 2014
Lesley this is an excellent article. I know from my personal experience how important it is to have lipspeaking and signed support too. It really helps a lot, as you have highlighted. I know in the NADP ‘Walks and Talks’ events that we have organised, people in the group really appreciate that we have both lipspeaking and signed support available to make it accessible to everyone. I cannot praise the work that you do highly enough. Thank you so much for making it accessible to everyone, regardless of your communication needs.
Asher
September 27, 2014
Excellent article, I am currently studying to be a social worker and it is important for me to be aware of all deaf services so I can refer my future service users to appropriate services that they may need.
Lesley Weatherson
October 14, 2014
Sorry about my tardy reply only I’ve been working in Washington DC at the British Embassy using SSL. What an experience.
Cathy I am a qualified Lipspeaker and also Chair of the association of lipspeakers and founder director of Lipspeaker UK. I’m also a qualified nurse and midwife. I work full time as an SSL lipspeaker. There is plenty of work around but decided to train to be an interpreter so I may offer a full range of communication support to all deaf people.
Only the deaf community of BSL users can decide what happens culturally. BSL is a rich language and I hope it flourishes; I enjoy learning it and improving my skills.
I’m pleased others found the article interesting. I haven’t heard back from Signature regarding a qualification in SSL but watch this space…..
Best wishes to all.