The Work and Pensions Committee’s Access to Work report, published today, has heavily criticised the government’s Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) for changes to how the scheme has been run.
You can read the full report here, and there is also a BSL summary now online, which you can see by clicking here.
The report bluntly states that the changes have “threatened the employability” of Deaf British Sign Language (BSL) users.
To watch this article in BSL, with thanks to Matt Dixon, click play below. Read on below for the rest of the article.
Susan Daniels, CEO of the NDCS, says the report is a “damning indictment of how deaf and other disabled people have been supported by Access to Work (AtW), particularly in terms of customer service.”
Access to Work (AtW) is a scheme which offers support in employment to Deaf and disabled people, enabling them to get and keep their jobs.
The inquiry into the scheme was set up earlier this year after complaints from Deaf and disabled people about problems getting support.
The majority of the evidence sent to the inquiry came from Deaf people who use BSL to communicate at work.
Their evidence showed that the ’30 hour rule,’ and new limits on interpreters’ hourly rate of pay have had what the report calls “a profoundly detrimental impact” on Deaf people’s ability to get interpreting support.
Some Deaf people gave evidence that their AtW budgets had been reduced by 50% or more, and as a result, they were left without interpreting support or with invoices they could not pay.
The report says that AtW changes have “demonstrated a lack of understanding of how BSL interpretation is currently provided and used” and adds “DWP must work with service users and the BSL interpreting profession to fully resolve these issues as a matter of urgency.”
The scheme, sometimes described as the government’s best-kept secret, was also criticised for a “lack of transparency.”
Deaf people’s concerns that changes to the scheme have been motivated by a desire to cut costs are reflected in the report.
For example, the committee was told by the Disability Minister that the guidance for the scheme had been applied “in an attempt to control the costs of BSL support” because it accounted for a “disproportionately large amount of total AtW expenditure.”
The report says that in 2013/2014, 3,430 Deaf people received BSL interpretation, at a cost of “around £25 million,” or 24% of the expenditure of the scheme.
However, Dame Anne Begg MP, a member of the committee, said:
“The costs of BSL are relatively high but it would be unacceptable for DWP to try to control costs by targeting a particular group in a way which threatens people’s ability to stay in their jobs.
The Government has previously announced a temporary suspension of the”30 hour rule” but evidence suggests deaf people are continuing to face difficulties sourcing the BSL support they need.
DWP must address the issue as a matter of urgency, and fulfil its commitment to review the cases of all deaf service users who believe they have been adversely affected.”
The Committee has made a number of recommendations specifically aimed at Deaf BSL users in Section 4 of the report, stating:
- Cases should be reviewed where a BSL user believes that the ’30 hours rule’ or cap on interpreting rates has left them unable to get support.
- The DWP should re-issue guidance on when users should be given full-time support workers and this guidance should state that this “does not typically apply to BSL interpretation.”
- BSL interpreting organisations such as ASLI and NUBSLI should be consulted about rates of pay for interpreters.
- The DWP should consult on the “efficiency of the market for BSL interpreting services” and consider how to increase the number of interpreters.
- The DWP should set up a specially trained team to deal with high-cost AtW awards, including for BSL users. This team should have intensive Deaf-awareness training and be aware of all communication support methods.
- Technological solutions should be considered for communication support where “appropriate to needs and cost-effective.”
- All future changes to Access to Work policy and guidance should be consulted on with users, through a new users forum.
The report also recommends the DWP should:
- Introduce a Video Relay System for BSL users
- Increase the accessibility of ATW information, by producing easy to read content and BSL videos.
- Be clearer about how decisions are made and how people can complain or challenge an ATW decision.
- Establish an online application and invoicing system and a web portal for ATW.
Read more responses from the Disability Minister and deaf organisations by clicking here.
By Charlie Swinbourne, Editor
The Limping Chicken is the UK’s deaf blogs and news website, and is the world’s most popular deaf blog.
Make sure you never miss a post by finding out how to follow us, and don’t forget to check out what our supporters provide:
- Phonak: innovative technology and products in hearing acoustics
- Ai-Live: Live captions and transcripts
- Bellman: hearing loss solutions
- Deaf Umbrella: sign language interpreting and communications support
- SignVideo: Instant BSL video interpreting online
- 121 Captions: captioning and speech-to-text services
- The Royal Court Theatre: Accessible plays with captions and BSL translation
- Doncaster School for the Deaf: education for Deaf children
- Signworld: online BSL learning and teaching materials
- Exeter Deaf Academy: education for Deaf children
- SignHealth: healthcare charity for Deaf people
- Lipspeaker UK: specialist lipspeaking support
- STAGETEXT: theatre captioning
- CJ Interpreting: communication support in BSL
- SDHH: Deaf television programmes online
- Sign Solutions:, language and learning
- Sign Lingual: BSL interpreting and communication services
- Action Deafness Communications: sign language and Red Dot online video interpreting
- Hamilton Lodge School in Brighton: education for Deaf children
- RAD: financial advice for Deaf people
- cSeeker: Online booking for communication support
- Krazy Kat: visual theatre with BSL
- Enable Support Services: Supporting Deaf children and adults in Suffolk, Essex, Cambridgeshire and Norfolk
- Sign Language Days: Sign language learning in schools
John David Walker
December 19, 2014
Following the report, here is the Minister of Disabled People’s, Mark Harper, response: http://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/written-questions-answers-statements/written-statement/Commons/2014-12-18/HCWS139/
Clearly, there are no promises.
pennybsl
December 19, 2014
Today is a “WE TOLD YOU SO” day, but tingled with sadness at the wreckage of many Deaf workers’ lives, BSL Interpreters’ lives, careers development and employers’ trust – huge, huge damage caused by the DWP/AtW “perfect storm”.
It is gobsmackingly incredible how we witnessed in this day and age, taxpayer-paid DWP/AtW staff instructed to treat us in ways that would give them the sack if they behaved like that in customer services elsewhere.
Human Rights issues were broken in the UK, who signed the UN document on the civil rights of disabled people.
Clearly, with the damning report, there is a real case for compensation for the victims, especially those who lost or stepped down from responsible jobs under the onslaught of AtW restrictions in the past 2 years.
The searing honesty and transparency of the Select Committee’s words gives us hope, like a small Christmas gift – yes, small, because our trust in Parliament and the Civil Service took a heavy hammering in the AtW process.
Trust, once lost, never returns into its original size.
Thank you all campaigners.
Linda Parkin
December 19, 2014
Thank you to Limping Chicken for writing a useful summary, also a BSL version, so quickly. We have shared it in RAD’s Facebook group.
Darren Townsend-Handscomb
December 19, 2014
This is a really good report.
If you were one of the many people who sent evidence to the Select Committee, helped other people to send evidence, gave evidence at the oral sessions, or in other ways worked with the Select Committee to help them understand the issues, then you should feel proud. Your evidence had a big impact and helped them get this right.
Take a few minutes to appreciate that we can sometimes make a difference 🙂
What can you do now?
1) If you are still having problems with your AtW, or are an interpreter and are still owed money, etc. then complain to the PHSO now. PHSO are investigating complaints about AtW now, and their findings may cause AtW to make changes. It’s harder for AtW to ignore the PHSO’s recommendations than it is is for them to ignore the Select Committee. More information the DeafATW PHSO page.
Also, the Select Committee recommendations may help AtW customers in general, but if you want your problems with AtW to be sorted out, go to the PHSO.
2) Join Stop the Changes and NUBSLI. The more people they represent, the stronger they can campaign on our behalf. As a member you can also talk with them about what you think they should do.
3) Talk to your MP. Tell everyone else to talk to their MP. The election is coming up soon, and MPs care about your vote. Tell them that you will be voting for the party that agrees to implement the Select Committee recommendations in full, and properly supports Deaf and disabled people to work. Let’s make it an issue fro Conservatives, Labour, Liberal Democrats, UKIP, Greens and all.
For other suggestions, more discussion and links – go to:
http://www.deafatw.com/updates.html