Last night, it was reported that there’s been a breakthrough in treating genetic hearing loss as gene editing has been shown to prevent progressive deafness in mice.
To watch this article in BSL, signed by Elizabeth Bojas from Reflect BSL, click play below, or scroll down to continue in written English.
When I read this, my mind went straight back to Ted Evans’ award-winning film The End that featured a ‘treatment’ much like the one reported yesterday, that ‘cured’ deafness.
The film showed all the ramifications that this ‘treatment’ brought with it, including the end of deafness, and consequently, Deaf culture.
The final scene had Deaf people in tears. (Spoiler alert) It showed the last Deaf man in Britain, then zoomed out to reveal that he was now a museum exhibit, appearing on a screen in the future.
It could be argued that as science advances, the prospect of The End becoming real seems almost inevitable in the future.
It brings with it all kinds of questions. For Deaf people, who value our Deaf world and feel a strong sense of Deaf identity, it is immensely sad to think that one day our culture and language may be in the past.
I was lucky enough to grow up in the Deaf community, with Deaf parents and brothers, often visiting the local Deaf club, seeing amazing stories told in sign language richer than any film I could see at the cinema.
There may be better descriptions of Deaf culture, but for me, the ideas, customs and social behaviour of Deaf people, which makes up our culture, comes from Deaf people being together, seeing the world visually, communicating in sign language, reading lips, and sharing the same experiences.
Beautiful things have come from that culture. I’ve seen great plays starring Deaf actors, hilarious stand-up comedy from John Smith and the Deaf Comedians. I’ve seen sign poetry and Visual Vernacular performances and hilarious Deaf comedy films.
But for me, better than all of those things is seeing a Deaf storyteller signing a funny story at the end of the bar at a Deaf club, keeping a crowd rapt with only the power of his hands, body and face.
Deafness, of course, has its challenges. Society as a whole has a lack of deaf awareness, there’s a lack of access to services, and not enough people know even a basic level of sign language. This makes elements of Deaf life difficult.
But those negatives create a kind of defiance, a close-knit community which is proud of what it is, protective and supportive of each other – in much the same way as people from other minority groups stick together.
In the last few years I’ve made a series of documentaries called Found, about Deaf people whose lives changed when they discovered the Deaf world, sign language and a new community (I’m currently making episodes 4 and 5).
The people I’ve interviewed have regularly described the Deaf world as finding a home, a place where they belonged. One woman last week told me that she would not be here today if she had not found it.
So many people in the wider world don’t understand Deaf culture for the exact same reason that Deaf culture exists – communication.
People will see someone signing and say how beautiful it is, but few go on to learn it. And without learning, how can you really know how Deaf people feel, what makes our world beautiful, how it is every bit the equal of the non-Deaf universe?
For those who live in the hearing world, the Deaf world seems alien, and the superiority of the hearing world is assumed without a moment’s thought.
Yet to Deaf people, it is the hearing world that can appear alien, often hostile, unthinking, unempathetic. The idea that the hearing world is superior – when it neglects and marginalises Deaf people and sign language – can seem laughable.
In a world where people spend much of their lives looking down at screens, being part of a culture which is based on strong eye contact (we could not say anything to each other without it) brings a human connection that many people in the non-deaf world lament the disappearance of (if you want to connect, come and join us).
I could tell hearing people now what a tragedy the loss of Deaf culture would be, but it’d be a shame if they just took my word for it. It would be much better if they went out there, learned some sign language, and met Deaf people, so they could realise the Deaf world’s beauty for themselves – while it lasts.
Please sign Charlie’s petition for better cinema access for Deaf people, here.
Charlie Swinbourne is a journalist and is the editor of Limping Chicken, and is also an award-winning filmmaker and screenwriter. Charlie has just set up his own media production company, Eyewitness Media. Both episodes of his new sketch comedy in BSL, Deaf Funny, can be seen on the BSL Zone website.
Chris Bradley
December 21, 2017
Even ignoring my personal pain at suffering from a cruel disability(and i too went to a deaf club and had a deaf family) i have knpwn others who have gone as far as commit suicidr because of the misery they have endured. People who struggled to earn a living in the real world not some charity funded enterprise of mutual backslapping
You won’t print this anyway so all i can say is congratulations you have somehow managed to polish a turd
Lianne Herbert
December 22, 2017
Just letting you know your comment has been published by responding to it.
Can I ask how Charlie polished the turd?
Chris Bradley
December 22, 2017
Sorry was in a mood when i wrote that comment. There is a saying which goes ….you can’t polish a turd. Which means you can’t make out something bad is good. Could have worded it better i think.
There was a comment by Paddy Ladd in which he referred to the hard work of doctors and scientists in trying to help the deaf as….the final solution….that showed stunningly bad taste when you consider it was originally used by the nazis to describe their genocide of the jews through industrial level torture and murder. So we all make careless comments
Sorry
Editor
December 22, 2017
Thanks for saying sorry, but saying Deaf culture is effectively a turd is offensive to me. Could you tell me how much you know of the deaf world?
Robert Erdelen
December 21, 2017
Excellent article, Charlie. We live in Detroit, Michigan (USA) and my wife is deaf. She became deaf late in life. We took two courses of ASL at our local community college about 8 years ago – and I must say that I enjoyed the experience. My wife later received a Cochlear implant which restored a great deal of her ability to hear. Unfortunately that caused me (lazy to a fault) to let my ASL skills seriously fall off.
This article is an inspiration for a new year’s resolution to go back for more ASL classes in 2018 and relearn what I’ve forgotten (and then some).
I seldom make a comment, but I enjoy your emails / postings.
donaldo of the wasatch
December 21, 2017
I have not posted in a while. Anyone with two cents of sensibility knows this was and is happening. It has been happening for 2-3 decades now. The DC has not made itself amenable to this inevitability except to complain, whine, and having a cultural tantrum fit. Deaf education has a three fold purpose – literacy, competency and fluency. The tragedy is that they geared up for a “DC” cultural context which does not did not nor will not prepare its traditional constituencies for such in a hearing world.
Who fault is this? The DC. No one else. You acculturated folks to be literate, competent and fluent in the Deaf Culture Context, not the hearing world. Just like corporations or any organization that does not accept change, they will become ilrelevant. Want to complain, forget it. You will be yanked off the stage of humanity and relegated to museum pieces.
I AM DEAF. One hundred percent deaf. With hearing aids and later cochlear implants I excelled! the Deaf Culture was totally irrelevant to my needs and expectations. At the end of the tunnel what do you have to offer? The screed of “cultural genocide”? Nope it is “cultural suicide.” Like Frank Sinatra sang “I did it my way.” So did I. I made myself relevant to 100% of the opportunities available to me. So basically as Charlie says – you will become museum pieces. Great insight Charlie. I do not pity you. I am just devastated by the poor counsel that your overlords in the monasteries of silence gave you. You were mislead.
Yes you have wonderful qualities. Why did not you not share and offer that to society as a whole? NO you chose the “cult” card from the deck. Look up the definitions and attributes of cults.
Editor
December 21, 2017
Could you tell me the extent of your experiences in the Deaf world donaldo?
donaldo of the wasatch
December 28, 2017
62 years of being in and around it. That counts for something! 66 years of living in a hearing culture too at the same time. I watched and was the poster child of a emerging group that was exceptional in every respect, breaking barriers and accomplishing milestones that were consider socially, intellectually and educationally impossible. The only place I really struggled with was employment because the reputation of the Deaf Culture members terrified them and tainted my efforts.
Lianne Herbert
December 22, 2017
Care to explain what you meant by this?
“I am just devastated by the poor counsel that your overlords in the monasteries of silence gave you. You were mislead.”
Everyone has different experiences on deafness. Doesn’t mean we should bring each other down.
Tim
December 22, 2017
Indeed, Lianne.
Donaldo’s was a glorified straw man argument, stuffing words into people’s mouths and deeds into their hands, none of which they would ever dream of saying or doing. It happens when a person only sees things in black and white, missing all the grey areas.
Most people agree to disagree when they differ with somebody elses’s opinion and do not treat their own view as if it’s the definitive article. After all, none of us can know for sure if we are right.
Tata
December 21, 2017
I agree 100% with the comment of Donaldo of the Wasatch.
Alison
December 22, 2017
Wow! Moving on…
Chris Bradley
December 22, 2017
In reply to Charlie….i am from a deaf family. Teo of my uncles were chairmen of 2 seperste deaf clubs bothof which no longer exist as the general trend is these days. I was mainstreamed but briefly went to a school with a PHU.
I used to devour a tv programme called See Hear in the hope of finding the answer to my misery and saw other deaf going all over the world etc apparently having a good time and follollowed the story of Durham University (i think) studying sign language with the help of deaf people including the Denmarks and the birth of BSL and leading on to degrees in Deaf Culture and (no connection) the proliferation of Deaf charities……
You stick to your coping strategy and i will stick to mine. Merry Xmas
Editor
December 22, 2017
What led you to reject the Deaf community? Each to their own but I wondered what the reasons were.
Chris Bradley
December 22, 2017
I can’t find the deaf community. Deaf get togethers in my area happen once a month and are attended by about 6-7 pensioners. I have nothing against the aged by the way just limitted in mutual interests.
Even in the “glory days” of club membership there were no other deaf of my age that attended. Back then there would be 20 or so deaf attending and about 15 of them were uncles and cousins.
I have paid money to learn sogn and baffled the teacher when he askrd me to come forward and then signed ….whats your name?. . To which i replied in sign including my age and what job i had. I guess i was supposed to not understand him. I remember chatting with a deaf worker for a charity and saying that being deaf….i get it(about sign) just need to increase my vocabulary of signs snd she recommended a good book which potentially saved me thousands.
We would probably get on Charley but beware i am notoriously cynical about many things
Editor
December 22, 2017
Thanks for this. Where are you based? Perhaps we could have a cuppa one day.
Chris Bradley
December 22, 2017
Burnley snd you are very welcome. Once again….Mery Xmas to you and yours
Editor
December 22, 2017
I live half an hour from you! Drop me an email editor@limpingchicken.com and we could have a cuppa in the new year?
Chris Bradley
December 22, 2017
Will do….
Editor
December 22, 2017
Cool, cheers
Hartmut Teuber
December 23, 2017
A challenge question could be asked to hearing and deaf persons: How would you entertain the possibility that EVERYONE is hearing (or in reverse NO-ONE of the humanity were deaf)? I got a good number of hearies with no exposure to deaf people who opined that such a humanity would be awful. The expectation of some hearing persons that everyone hears, that a person is whole if his hearing is intact, is a germ of a future audistic attitude with subsequent discriminatory behavior toward deaf people.
One point about the use of the phrase “hearing loss”: I have stopped using this deficitiary term since 1975. When talking about deafness, I simply use “inability to hear” or “diminished ability to hear” only to explain my not hearing noises and understanding speech. I would simply say “I don’t hear” instead of “I cannot hear” or “I lost my hearing when I …”. Loss of something implies attempts to find or recover it. Although I became deaf at the age of 2 1/2 years, I never searched for hearing! Since I don’t search for it, there is no point of talking about “hearing loss”. When I say “I am deaf”, it refers 100% to my being deaf and living as such, the whole thing from top to my soles.
So better avoid this term like a pest!
I am deaf, but not my ears!
Marika Rebicsek
December 27, 2017
Very interesting comments here. Don’t forget that genetic repair will not stop or prevent ALL deafness, just a small minority. I don’t think there will ever be a total 100% cure for deafness. What about people who cannot use speech? They use sign language too. Also in The End, one issue I thought was extremely well put over was that okay can cure deafness, maybe brilliant cochlear implants but unless you treat the whole person, not just the hearing but the whole person and help them adjust to hearing culture, you are going to create a person with serious mental health issues. I don’t think Deaf culture and Deaf community will die out, not at least for many years. I hope not as it is the community and culture I am most comfortable in and can truly be MYSELF – Marika, Deaf, happy and contented with it, though I wish I could have the use of my hearing aids back just to make it a bit easier to cope in the hearing world, but I am quite happy as a Deaf person and it took me many years to adjust and become to where I am now and that is thanks to embracing BSL and Deaf culture. I was born to hearing parents – who were fantastic – and grew up oral but always something missing in my life until I found MY people, at the age of 17, the Deaf community (through the Catholic Deaf Association and signed Masses). Thank you for sharing. I am going to recommend my L3 students read this page as it is a good topic for discussion for their 3rd exam!
chris bradley
December 31, 2017
Marika….as a sign language tutor would it be fair to say you rely on the existence of deaf people as your income? Why also do you insist on using the capital D? I look forward to your reply