Recently I was at a conference chatting to a dude I’d just met, and it transpired that his research was all about auditory processing technology for hearing aids. “Oooh,” I said with great professionalism, “That’s super cool! I’m profoundly deaf and I use hearing aids, so your work is personally relevant to me!”
He looked at me. “You use hearing aids?”
“Yes,” I said smugly, waiting for him to get excited about meeting someone who was an end user of his research, and/or tell me that he would never have guessed I had a hearing loss (people do this a lot; they seem to think it’s a compliment).
“Not a cochlear implant.”
“Ye-es,” I said a bit more uncertainly.
“So you’re hard of hearing. Not deaf.”
UM, DUDE, I wanted to say, I AM SUPER DEAF. Actually, that might’ve been what I did say. To be honest I was so taken aback I’m not sure exactly what I did say. It might be the only time in my life that I’ve lived what ‘flabbergasted’ means. I was gasted all over my flabber.
If you’re not a hearing expert– ‘profoundly deaf’ is a very specific technical term. It means that your average hearing threshold (the quietest sound you can hear), is at least 95 decibels.
Pretty sure no-one who actually has a hearing loss has ever accidentally called themselves profoundly deaf when they meant ‘hard of hearing’ (which is not a technical term, but is usually used to describe people who have mild to moderate hearing loss).
Incredibly, however, this is not even the first time in my life I have had someone straight up tell me to my face that I must be WRONG about how deaf I am. I cannot possibly be profoundly deaf, apparently, because I:
– don’t have a cochlear implant
– use my voice
– am not very good at BSL (British Sign Language), apart from the swear words
– went to a mainstream school rather than a school for the deaf
Mateys, you do not get to tell my story. I contain multitudes. I can be profoundly deaf and go to a school with hearing people and play an instrument and be terrible at sign language and use hearing aids and sing cheerfully to my cats when I’m alone in the house. It doesn’t make me less deaf.
The frustrating thing about these weird preconceptions about deaf people is that I have to spend a good deal of time unexpectedly justifying myself to other people. Yes, I really am deaf. No, I know I don’t sound like it. Lipreading, mostly, but my hearing aids help too. I don’t think a cochlear implant is right for me at the moment. Sorry, I’m just really wiped out from lipreading all day. Sorry, just to remind you that you need to face me when you talk. Sorry, you’re covering your mouth again.
It’s exhausting.
P.S. Sometimes when I’m chatting to my friends and I unexpectedly hear something I wouldn’t normally (e.g. someone’s back is turned when they ask if I want some tea and I go YES PLEASE because I am always highly attuned to the tea-offering wavelengths of speech), they often squint at me and say ARE YOU REALLY DEAF and I throw my head back and with great drama say NO, I HAVE FOOLED YOU, I AM A FAKE DEAFY, but this is OK because we are among friends and it is all part of the many delights of being friends with me. If you do this and you are a stranger, you’re just being a dick.
Sophie Meekings is a speech scientist based in Newcastle. She says: “I research how the voice works in people who’ve got a stammer and people with Tourette’s Syndrome. In my spare time I volunteer as an outdoor educator for a national children’s charity, teaching children how to set fire to things! You can find out more about my research at sophiemeekings.com and I tweet at @sophiemeekings.”
Eileen
May 16, 2018
Love it!!! So true for me as well.
elmosdogblog
May 16, 2018
Yep, yep, yep – relate to all of that though I’ve yet to have a researcher tell me I’m not deaf enough. ☺
Sam Thorne
May 16, 2018
Great article! And your hearing reality much reflects mine.
You made me giggle and seethe on your behalf, too
Jo Dennison Drake
May 16, 2018
I have exactly the same problem in that my speech is better than a lot of badly spoken hearing people so it’s only those that are deaf aware that realise that I’m ‘probably’ deaf as I focus intensely on their faces to lip read and perhaps see my hearing aids. So I sympathise with Sophie here completely. I also sometimes can hear words if the situation is right. My hearing loss is severe on the first two frequencies on the audiogram and then it drops to profound hearing loss for the remainder. I can still use the telephone with my family with difficulty as long as they talk on familiar ground. As soon as they change subject it takes a bit of guessing to work it out and they are usually very good at flexing their choice of words to get me back on track.
Additionally this is the weird bit. I once helped a deaf lady who I presumed was much deafer than me on the phone as she said she couldn’t hear on the phone and then when she once saw my audiogram she said she had more hearing than me. I think it’s more about how one listens and uses every bit of what hearing they have that can make all the difference. Having said that now I’m older I find it much harder and my audiologist said something about the brain gets less efficient at processing the speech sounds. Perhaps she was politely telling me I was suffering the early stages of dementia!!!! I’m 58 so that hurt a bit!
Last month I acquired new hearing aids from the NHS and it’s a nightmare! Just the usual Phonax which I’ve had for years. I can’t hear speech very well at all suddenly but am brilliant at hearing new sounds that I’ve never heard before. I could hear my phone make a noise announcing a new message had come through from another room, I can hear the clock ticking if it’s quiet in the background and I can hear birds tweeting in the garden if it’s quiet too! The new hearing aids totally amplify wind, road noise, traffic but not speech! Grrr! The hearing aids are up to their max settings so can’t do anything about it.
Sarah Playforth
May 16, 2018
Hi Sophie, you describe my life almost perfectly – aside from being:
1. much much older than you
2. probably with better BSL (due to 1)
3. about to have my CI switched on (because of no longer being able to wear hearing aids). I’ve been called hard of hearing by hearing and deaf people as well as medics, even when I’ve introduced myself as deaf and lipreading. Good article. All the best.
jon reeves
May 16, 2018
Great article – I’ve recently had a major loss to my hearing and am now classed as moderately deaf although I think I need retesting as its getting worse but I tick all your boxes above – peoples reactions range from bizarre to interested to stand offish – proving hard too as I work in face to face sales!
Anon
May 16, 2018
Enjoyed reading this!
Kelly A Dougher
May 16, 2018
You’re a really funny writer Sophie, and I love that we seem to be living pretty much the same life but in different countries. Everything here was spot-on.
Leigh
May 16, 2018
My support worker Elizabeth Woodall has just sent me your article, it’s my life also.
I’m not deaf enough too apparently, so says a Consultant! I struggle daily with my hearing aid and lipreading, but with some familiar voices i can be a little more tuned in to their speech patterns.
These professionals can only understand to a point of reference, unless th ey have hearing loss themselves.
We all have different degrees of loss and different strategies to manage our loss, in fact I will probably upset some people but we are made to feel we live in “no man’s land” neither hearing not born deaf…it’s a whole other world.
Breish
May 16, 2018
I would have liked to have seen more of a polished ending to this article. By that I mean details of what followed the hearing person’s statement and the final response by the author. Other than that, great article and interesting to read!
Martyn
May 16, 2018
I also relate to all that, but I’ve not yet had the pleasure of being insulted by a mildly/moderately/severely/profoundly stupid researcher. (Should we take a vote?)
Isabel Brett
May 17, 2018
Relate! My family still don’t believe me but I’m not surprised as they have booming voices but they still try and talk through walls!
Leeanne
May 18, 2018
Love this. This is my daily life struggles since becoming severe to profoundly deaf 8 years ago. I used to shrug or laugh off the stupidity but lately I have begun to find it quite offensive and rude. Frustrating is an understatement but thank you for this as it makes me feel not quite so alone.