In a case that shines a spotlight on the problems that deaf people face in the prison system, the BBC has reported the mother of a deaf prisoner saying that her son ‘would still be alive if not for the failures of prison staff.’
Tyrone Givans, who was 32, killed himself at HMP Pentonville on 26 February 2018 after spending three weeks on remand accused of Actual Bodily Harm.
Givans had mental health and alcohol problems. In one of the startling details released at the inquest, it was revealed that he had had spent nearly a month in prison without his hearing aid.
The BBC article says:
Mr Givans’ mother Angela Augustin told the BBC that her son was a calm and humble young man.
“He was always bubbly and smiling – when people saw Tyrone they would just see this big massive smile,” she said.
Mr Givans was being held on remand at the north London prison – but threatened to kill himself before he arrived.
The prisoner’s mental health issues and suicidal ideations were insufficiently addressed by the prison and healthcare services, Mary Elizabeth Hassell, senior coroner for inner north London said.
At the hearing, a number of prison staff accepted they should have opened suicide and self-harm monitoring procedures had they known of his history of suicidal ideation.
Read the full article here.
Agatha Peabody
February 4, 2019
They should have given him his hearing aids.. myself with a few others are restarting the Deaf Prisoners Project. Too late to help this poor guy, but let us stop this from happening again.
Patricia Parke
February 4, 2019
I agree with you, Agatha. This poor guy should be given his hearing aids automatically! The prison system is in chaos and they have failed their duty of care for other Deaf and disabled prisoners. I am very interested to join your project as I have a lot to say!
Tim
February 4, 2019
Very sad case, so many things done wrong.
I’m glad to learn from Agatha above that the Deaf prisoners’ project is starting again, that is much needed.
Diana B Laing
February 4, 2019
Makes me wonder of us in Australia, are the authorities up to date on Deafness related issues??? Good luck to you Agatha on this project, a worthy cause to follow up on.
belinda
February 7, 2019
No different to some mental health wards for deaf people
Lack of deaf awareness and equality is appauling
Mary
February 25, 2019
This takes me back to a situation where a Deaf prisoner had his TV removed because of ‘bad behaviour’. This was the prisons policy. But, if hearing prisoners had their TV removed they were still allowed a radio. When an explanation regarding the prisoners Deafness, was explained to the prison officer. That the removal of the TV would be the equivelant of solitary confinement to the Deaf prisoner, as he will have no stimulation or external input. The reply was rules are rules and they have to be followed regardless of disability….
No reasonable adjustment or equality!
British prison service need to address this issue. No rehabilitation is possible if there is no communication….