The BBC has reported this morning that Channel 4 subtitles and sign language interpretation are not likely to return on TV until mid-November.
For weeks, deaf people have been missing their favourite programmes like Bake Off, Gogglebox, 24 Hours in A&E, and many more, following the incident at Red Bee Media’s London offices.
There have been over 500 complaints to Ofcom.
One of the main complaints deaf people have had is about the lack of communication from the broadcaster, and a lack of timescale for when the programmes will become accessible again.
The news that it will be mid-November will give some sense of certainty, but also will lead to dismay that there will be another four weeks without access.
The only positive news is that some programmes will be made accessible on catch-up service All4 (see below).
Caroline O’Neill from the group Deaf and Disabled People in TV, said:
We’re happy that C4 are being transparent and honest and finally offering a timeline for full access service restoration. This kind of communication is crucial, but more than anything we need reassurances that this will not happen again and we find the monopoly over these services extremely concerning. We hope lessons have been learned from this incident and ask that C4 continue to provide us with updates on accessible content.
The National Deaf Children’s Society has responded to Channel 4’s announcement that full access services might not return until mid-November.
Mike Hobday, Director of Policy and Campaigns at the National Deaf Children’s Society, said:
“It is simply not good enough that Channel 4 has said they will not solve the subtitling issues until at least mid-November. This is almost two months. If there was no sound on TV, there would be a huge outcry.
“Channel 4 have been celebrated as champions for disability, but they are now failing deaf young people who simply want to watch TV with their friends and family. The delay in resolving this problem is completely unacceptable.
“Ofcom must now take strong regulatory action.”
Further details from the BBC report:
- Full access services won’t be back until the middle of November.
- Sign language and audio description services were lost during the incident and won’t be restored until they move to the new system Red Bee are building.
- The broadcaster will begin to offer subtitles for its biggest shows like The Great British Bake Off and Gogglebox on its online catch-up service All4 from this week.
- An Ofcom spokesperson told the BBC: “We expect Channel 4 to meet the timetable it has set out for restoring these vital services.”
srhplfrth
October 19, 2021
I’m amazed at this incompetence. Ok, subtitles on All4 is something but how can we possibly catch up with everything we’ve missed with another month of inaccessible programmes building up? We don’t have the luxury of time to do nothing but watch television or the desire to do so, most of us do go out, have jobs and a social life and for those not able to get out or who are ill, lonely or isolated, this failure of access is especially upsetting. I don’t understand why channel 5 can improve this sooner than channel 4 either. I’m tired of tweeting and reading tweets about this, of seeing no news ‘news’ about it so it’s ‘good’ to have a timescale but the whole debacle is appalling!
Ian D
October 19, 2021
Two months without subtitles. OK, let’s turn off the sound for two months. No? Why not? Hearies don’t want to be without sound; equally Deafies don’t want to be without subtitles and signing. They are not a luxury, not something that is of low priority for the broadcasters. The fact that they’re building a new IT system for the subtitles, as mentioned in the article, is proof that the original system was deleted by some member of Red Bee staff by mistake, and that there was no backup system. Lack of communication from Red Bee? Yes there was, but it’s not the main problem. It’s the lack of subtitles and we Deafies need to keep on complaining to C4 and Ofcom (500 complaints clearly not enough when we are battling against the hearies!) It’s not good enough at all, especially with the prospect of us Deafies going without subtitles for a further 4 (or 5, 6, 7….) weeks. Shame on C4, C5 and BBC!
Jane taylor
October 19, 2021
I find this disgusting. Completely a different story if the hearing couldn’t hear the tv. Deaf people need this sorted before two week time. Or money back from the tv license would help.
Cathy
October 19, 2021
So, we have a rough idea of how long it will be before subtitles return, but I wonder how channel 5 have managed to restore subs, yet channel 4 has not?! What is really going on here? They should both be restored at the same rate, given they all use the same system. Some programmes are on catch-up but who has time to endlessly catch up on 2 months of programmes? I certainly don’t. This is discrimination for sure and deafies everywhere should sue the corporation and give them a wake up call.
n123
October 21, 2021
It will be interesting to see if this new system will work better than the old system – I always hated it when subtitles were out of sync – hopefully new system avoids this problem – silver lining in every cloud….