The other day, my toddler and I took our car to have some work done to it at a garage in a nearby town. We were greeted by a rather annoying salesman-type manager person, who was probably also working part time as a game show host.
You know the type? Sharp suit, stiff hair, far too much fake smiling going on. One of those.
Anyway, I was a bit late and keen to be on my way, so when the annoying manager asked:
“Can your daughter hear? Yes? Good!”
I didn’t challenge him. I just glared at him, and took pleasure in the fact that my daughter glared at him too. Despite being only two years old, she can be quite frightening.
You see, it’s happened before – I’ve been asked the same “hearing” question about my son, and other questions like that too. “Is your son deaf too? No? Good!”, that sort of thing.
A woman at a party once asked me, “Do you work?” and wasn’t quite polite enough to cover up her surprise when I said yes. Then, she asked me what I did, and practically fell over when I told her that I taught English, because well, that’s what I did at the time.
What exactly is so wrong with being deaf?
Thinking about the car salesman/gameshow host: I had just driven (yay! deaf people can actually drive!) up to his office building, in my 4×4 (guess what? deaf people drive shamefully large cars that are bad for the environment too!), with my daughter in the back (and wow! they even let us have children! fancy that!).
Which part of that scenario told him that it was “good” not to be deaf?
Thinking about the impolite woman at the party: Er, why can’t deaf people work? (Actually, she told me later on that she used to work with a deaf person. Oh. Not sure what to think about that one either.)
I don’t get it.
I know deaf people who do all sorts of things; for example, we’re HGV drivers, solicitors, teachers, doctors, nurses, actors, artists, geeks, scientists, managers, students, parents, factory workers and postal workers.
I even know a deaf woman who lives in the Orkney Islands, doing accountancy for a company that installs wind turbines, and in her spare time, she power lifts. Oh yes. Deaf people are strong too! And good at maths.
Come to think of it, I actually even know of a deaf person who sells cars, just like Mr Stiff Hair! And, I can think of quite a few deaf people who would make fantastic game show hosts, but I’m going off the subject here.
My point, really, is: why do some people automatically think negatively of deaf people?
Obviously, not everyone does – this is not an attack on hearing people, but a genuine question – what is supposed to be so bad about being deaf? Also, why is it OK to comment on it?
It would be much nicer if everyone was like the random hearing woman that I met this morning. When I told her I was deaf, not ignoring her, she said “Oh, I’m sorry I don’t know any sign language. Do you… read lips?”
There you go – respect.
Jen Dodds is a Contributing Editor for The Limping Chicken. When she’s not looking after chickens or children, Jen can be found translating, proofreading and editing stuff over at Team HaDo Ltd (teamhado.com).
The Limping Chicken is the UK’s independent deaf news and deaf blogs website, posting the very latest in deaf opinion, commentary and news, every weekday! Don’t forget to follow the site on Twitter and Facebook, and check out our supporters on the right-hand side of this site or click here.
Andy. Not him, me.
October 28, 2013
I think the answer is “status”. Being deaf causes people to be seen as low in status.
What is status? Well you might ask. If I could bottle it I would make Bill Gates look a pauper.
It is almost indefinable but it is the idea that some people deserve more respect than others. It is not new. The Native Americans had a thing called a totem pole. It depicted the status of the tribal leadership. So the Chief was at the top, the sub chiefs lower down. Everyone knew their place.
From here comes the saying “Low man on the totem pole”. The bit that gets peed on by dogs.And that is how it is for deaf people we are low man on the totem. It seems that just the act of being deaf strips away any status we might have.
Of course, not everyone is like that. Most hearing people are OK but when it comes to something that really matters their true feelings come out. Many hearing people are just pretending to be “nice” about disability issues because they don’t want to be seen as not being with the program. When it comes to the nitty gritty, when we directly compete with them, that’s when their true feelings come out.
The fact is, hearing people are jostling for status with each other all the time. They drive great big cars, have expensive jewellery dripping off them, the pretend to be far more affluent than they really are. Impressing other people is a serious hearing game. But most deaf people don’t play that game. generally we have different values, we place more importance on people’s character than their wealth and possessions. We tend to take people as we find them and be very accepting.
pennybsl
October 28, 2013
That is why “inclusion” is a misnomer when there are at least three-quarters of deaf children alone in mainstream schooling with minimal /zero peers (according to CRIDE http://www.ndcs.org.uk/document.rm?id=7642l ). ‘Poor deaf mite’ perhaps was the most common refrain in people’s minds as the solitary deaf kids struggled bravely through barriers in education, home and social.
People who grew up and interacted with deaf peers and Deaf professionals would never, ever say such idiotic – yes, IDIOTIC because it is 2013, not 1963 – things such as Jen described.
If we get a pound for every ‘idiotic / ignorant’ remark we Deafies receive throughout our lives, there wouldn’t be any need for DLA, we’d be rolling in Rolls Royce’s and BMWs.
Tim
October 28, 2013
I think it’s two things – lack of empathy and arrogance.
Lack of empathy means that if you’re not like the hearing person s/he thinks there ‘must be something missing or wrong with you.’
Arrogance sometimes means that not only do they insist that there is something wring you, but they also insist that you must be fixed. Take a look at at an earlier post at LC for an example of this arrogance. It’s called ‘Deaf News: The Ear Foundation call for more cochlear implants for deaf adults.’
That is full of arrogant talk about how Deafness causes this and that disaster. It never occurs to the authors that maybe it is bad attitudes and treatment of Deaf people that cause the problems. Respect, yes, and also diversity and inclusion – these are not empty buzz words, they mean something.
Tim
October 28, 2013
‘…something wring you…’ Oops! I meant ‘…something wrong with you…’
johnny fantastica
October 28, 2013
I had a good laugh at Jenny’s comments, yes whats wrong being Deaf?
I am artist, Author, Actor, Magician and in my young days good sportsman and proud to be Deaf.
Interesting point is during my Doctor Deaf Comedy show, I get a deaf person on stage and say as a Doctor will make him better and hear again, 9 out of 10 deaf persons panic and say no no I want STAY DEAF, wow ! have fun Johnny Fantastica
Martin
October 28, 2013
Laughed . . . paused . . erm, right, little different angle, Or is it a ‘wonderful’ thing for ‘praising’ deaf children? I recalled that I were given plenty of ‘praise’ when I was little lad, (maybe up to an office junior). Nowadays, I have to seek ‘praise’ . . . unsuccessfully!! Nowadays, I was often mistakenly ‘praised’ when paired with my kids (people tended to sweet up my kids until they realised that I was deaf not them)! It sadly appears that we are subconsciously ‘deaf caste’ in society? Are we? (knuckles *cracking*)
LJ.
October 28, 2013
… Lets be honest though, some deafies have an attitude about them and can be quite sarcastic towards others, I have seen how some can be when I’ve been out with them. (Note that I am profoundly deaf myself)
We have frustrations now and then just like everyone else and in today’s increasingly stressful climate we can only expect more unpleasantness towards us especially as most of us get some form of benefit like DLA. I sometimes get the ‘oh what’s wrong with you, on benefits’ stuff and it really gets to me.
People often think we have an easy time with lots of help thrown at us, It aint so as most of you probably know. I think the answer here is to hold tongue, grind teeth and carry on being pleasant to others in the way that we would like others to be pleasant to us.
Richard Duffy
October 29, 2013
I think it’s ignorance, but not necessarily a malicious kind of ignorance. It’s a case of genuinely never having come face to face with the issue, and therefore never really have given it much thought. Sound is such a huge part of how a hearing person experiences the world, so to confront them with the idea of experiencing the world without sound makes them think purely of it in terms of something lost, when really it’s something changed. It’s the change from how we’re used to experiencing things, a change to something so deeply ingrained that we take it completely for granted.
A hearing person, when confronted with the idea of deafness, can only think of how difficult it would be for them to make that seismic shift to a new way of experiencing the world, can only think of things in terms of how much they depend on sound, as opposed to how easy it can be once you do adjust to a new way of experiencing the world.
For example, I enjoy listening to music as I travel, I have big noise-cancelling headphones and can hear pretty much nothing but the music when I wear them. I would never wear these headphones to drive, or even cycle. That would terrify me. Those are things “I” can not do without my hearing. Yet deaf people do these things perfectly safely all the time, because they are more used to how to experience the world without sound.
It’s not that hearing people think it’s not possible, it’s that the time between being confronted with the idea, and reacting to it, only leaves enough time to think “I couldn’t do it” (even if, eventually, yes they could).
Lana
October 29, 2013
I do not care what hearing people think of us as Deaf but it bothers me when a family who has someone Deaf, dont bother to learn some BSL