I am a University student, currently in my second year and I am also deaf. My preferred language to communicate in is BSL although English is probably my first language due to growing up with a hearing non-signing family. I became deaf at the age of 3 due to meningitis and have had cochlear implants since then.
I wanted to raise awareness of the current injustice in the education system at University for deaf students. I strongly feel that deaf students are expected to do twice the work and spend more time than their peers on their studies, because the way things work at the moment is really not designed for us.
The first point I want to raise is the additional time and stress deaf students have in order to sort out their communication support at University. There are emails, meetings and paperwork about this and also, we have last minute cancellations when interpreters or note takers are unavailable, yet we are still expected to attend lectures or catch up ourselves when we have not been able to take part in seminars.
My hearing peers can just roll up to a lecture or seminar and expect to take part regardless of who turns up or not. I don’t have that sort of independence unfortunately. If there was a way that all lectures could be automatically captioned this would be brilliant for me and would also reduce the need for note takers to be there in person.
Secondly, there is clearly a barrier between BSL and English in the University system. Lectures aren’t designed for BSL at all. To be honest, when my interpreter relays information, several times I have to ask him to clarify which word the lecturer used.
Lots of BSL signs seem to have generic meanings, so it means through an interpreter I miss out on the exact english that my lecturer is using. From watching my interpreter, I also then have to translate what I’ve been watching into my English notes as my work is all submitted in written english. Again, this is extra time and effort that my peers do not even have to consider.
One of my favourite forms of support is palantypists – they type into a laptop and the words appear as they are typed on my screen. I can save these notes and use them in future, which is really useful.
The only issues here are firstly, there aren’t enough palantypists at all so they can’t cover all of my lectures. And secondly, the terminology used in the lectures means the information typed does contain typos or certain words get omitted. It isn’t perfect, but I find it the most helpful.
I have asked if I could deliver presentations in BSL in the past, to which my lecturer agreed. But I soon found that in order to ensure the English was voiced over accurately I had to write the presentation in English as well as deliver it in BSL, so it felt like I was doing twice the work!
Finally, social life at University still feels hard with the BSL/English barriers. Outings are often in dark dimly lit places and there’s just a real lack of deaf awareness on campus unfortunately. It still feels like I have to make the effort with everyone else instead of them meeting me half way or making an effort for me. My only options though are to either make an effort and exhaust myself lipreading or to be by myself. Not much fun really!
Courses aren’t written or delivered with deaf students in mind and the lack of consistent support means deaf students – like me – either have to accept the extra hard work that is required to succeed or admit defeat and be prepared to fail. I would like to see University’s having more deaf friendly accessible options that lessens the need for the same interpreter or palantypists at every lecture.
To be honest I have had my doubts about whether University is the right place for me but I love my subject very much and I am hopeful it will lead me to the career that I want. Maybe all of the double time and effort will pay off eventually, who knows.
But one thing is for sure, more awareness needs to be shared because University life as it is is not plain sailing for me and I imagine it may be the same for other deaf students.
This blog has been written anonymously as part of the Insight series – where readers are invited to share their story or news about their interesting job with The Limping Chicken. If you have a story to share please email rebecca@rawithey.com
Image courtesy of i-stock photos.
Michael
May 9, 2023
Good points. University is not properly accessible for deaf people. You have the double whammy of working in both English and BSL and often not getting the full understanding of the subject. You are absolutely right in the unfairness of “My hearing peers can just roll up to a lecture or seminar and expect to take part regardless of who turns up or not. I don’t have that sort of independence unfortunately”
I don’t have any answers to you – my university experience was a long time ago and then I skipped seminars – I didn’t know what was going on – and concentrated on working on my own in the library.
I would encourage you to keep at it. You love your subject and your degree might be a requirement for your career. For some subjects – English, History etc. – it gets easier at postgraduate level as you are expected to research and think for yourself.
As to social life – always difficult with hearing people. Some of my closest hearing friends usually knew me from sharing a house/flat.
Andrea Malyon
May 10, 2023
I feel your pain. When I studied, as a mature student who had hearing loss, I was fortunate in that my course was delivered by a private training organisation with the degree validated and confirmed by a university.
An induction loop was installed in all lecture rooms prior to me starting the course. I was also allowed to record lectures so that I could listen again in my own time. It was all quite exhausting despite this support,
I now work in a university where most lectures are recorded on Zoom with captions and a transcript available after the lecture. This is very helpful for me and quite honestly if this was not done for large meetings too I wouldn’t be able to do my job.
You could ask about lectures being recorded at your university. So far as the social side goes I can’t help, I suffer pretty much the same as you. I find people watching fascinating 🧐.
Good luck with your studies and persevere, you can make your dream career happen.
Linzi
May 10, 2023
It shouldn’t be down to you to investigate but there are caption options through certain software including PowerPoint. I remember the people at Connevans showcasing a system that is designed for university students and was funded by DSA.