Rebecca A Withey: Why informed choices matter for parents of deaf children (BSL)

Posted on November 17, 2026 by

0



I recently taught a sign song workshop to children at a local school. They invite me back each year because the students are so enthusiastic about sign language.

Ever since a deaf student joined the school, they have made a real effort to learn more about the Deaf community, Deaf culture and sign language.

It made me wonder how different things might be if more schools had the opportunity, resources and knowledge to offer deaf children experiences like this.

When I first met this particular student last year, they were quiet and withdrawn. They sat at the side of the room, unsure about the workshop I was about to deliver.

They were bilaterally implanted and relied primarily on speech to communicate. Their teacher explained that their family didn’t use sign language, so I wasn’t sure how they would respond to what I was about to teach.

I wasn’t worried about teaching them, though. I’ve taught many non-signers before. I was simply curious to see whether they would enjoy it.

It’s fair to say that this child blew everyone away.

As I began teaching the song in sign — helped by the fact that, miraculously, it happened to be one of their favourite songs — the child gradually moved from sitting at the side of the room to standing in the centre, directly opposite me.

I couldn’t quite believe they hadn’t signed before.

They had a real knack for it. Their movements were incredibly expressive, and there was a real flair in the way their hands moved. You know when someone just seems to get something? It was like that.

At the end of the session, they shyly waved to me and left, with their teachers clearly delighted that they had participated and enjoyed themselves.

So when I returned again this year, I was surprised — and delighted — to find that the student’s parents had asked if they could come along to meet me.

When I chatted to them, I discovered that since the sign song session, their child had followed my work online, obsessively learnt more songs and discovered other deaf sign singers.

The parents told me that they had previously been discouraged from learning sign language and, as a result, hadn’t pursued it. That changed when their child came home absolutely gushing about the signed song they had learnt.

They also explained that, as first-time parents of a deaf child, they had been frightened that learning sign language might prevent their child from developing spoken English. They had received professional advice that placed a strong emphasis on speech therapy and mainstream education.

I found this particularly interesting because their child is now 11. It isn’t that long ago.

Since seeing such a positive change in their child’s enthusiasm and confidence, both parents have now begun BSL 101 courses.

And the fact that they wanted to meet me this year felt significant. They had been given a glimpse into another part of the Deaf community — one they hadn’t previously known much about.

Learning BSL and discovering signed song has given this child an opportunity to explore another way of communicating, expressing themselves and connecting with other deaf people.

They had also attended a local gathering for deaf children. Previously, they had mainly been able to chat with other deaf children who communicated orally. This time, they struck up a friendship with another child who uses sign.

A new friendship had formed. How lovely is that?

Yet this experience has made me think about how important the information given to parents of deaf children really is.

When a child is diagnosed as deaf, parents are often faced with an enormous amount of information and a huge number of decisions. They are understandably trying to work out what will give their child the best possible opportunities.

Most parents aren’t choosing one communication approach because they don’t care about the alternatives. They’re trying to make the best decision they can with the information they’ve been given.

That’s why the quality and breadth of that information matters so much.

I experienced this very personally when my own daughter was two and I felt that something was affecting her ability to develop spoken English.

I was told by a professional that her delayed speech was “to be expected for a deaf child”.

If I hadn’t been deaf myself, I might have accepted that explanation and assumed that nothing further needed investigating.

But I understood the difference between language and speech and knew that with the amount of residual hearing she had she could access speech sounds.

My daughter communicated fluently in BSL, but she was struggling to produce the lip patterns needed for spoken sounds.

So I followed my instinct, went to the Doctor and together we found a speech and language therapist who assessed her.

It turned out that she had verbal dyspraxia — a condition affecting the brain’s ability to plan and coordinate the movements needed to produce speech.

This required a very different type of speech and language support from the kind that might ordinarily be offered to a deaf child .

But because my daughter was given support that addressed her individual needs, rather than simply assuming that her difficulties were a consequence of being deaf, my daughter is now bilingual, using spoken English and BSL depending on who she is communicating with.

That experience really shaped the way I think about deaf children’s communication.

I am not saying that speech therapy will make every deaf child oral. Nor should that  be the aim. But it can give a child opportunities and skills that help them communicate in ways that work for them.

I feel we really need to see the whole child.

A child should not be discouraged from exploring BSL any more than they should be discouraged from accessing speech and language therapy.

And we must bear in mind that these things are offered as tools and opportunities — not as cures, fixes or measures of success.

My own parents were told that I needed to maximise my hearing aid use and attend speech therapy in order to function well in society.

Nobody told them about learning family sign language, meeting other deaf families or exploring different communication methods.

We had to learn a lot of it the hard way.

This is why I sincerely believe that when a child is diagnosed as deaf, families should be supported to understand the full range of options available to them.

Hearing aids.
Cochlear implants.
BAHAs.
Grommets.
Speech and language therapy.
BSL.
SSE.
Meeting other deaf children.
Connecting with Deaf adults.
Signed song.
Visual communication.
Art, Drama, Sports
Accessible education.

There isn’t one magic combination.

The right approach depends on the individual child, their hearing levels, their access to sound, their personality, their communication preferences, their additional needs, their family and the environments they are growing up in.

For some profoundly deaf children who gain little benefit from hearing aids or other amplification, an intensive focus on speech may become tiring or frustrating, particularly if it takes attention away from communication methods in which they are already thriving.

For another child with a moderate hearing loss who enjoys using hearing aids and communicates comfortably through spoken English, learning another language such as BSL may feel unnecessary or even overwhelming at a young age.

That child might instead thrive in an environment that is highly visual, accessible and designed to reduce listening fatigue.

Neither child is wrong and neither family is wrong. They simply have different needs. And that’s the point.

We need to ask the right questions –

What do they enjoy?
How do they communicate most naturally?
Where do they struggle?
What makes communication easier?
What helps them light up?
And what opportunities haven’t they been given yet?

For the child in my sign song workshop, perhaps signed song was simply a fun activity!

Or perhaps it gave them a form of expression that felt easier and more natural than speaking in front of a group.

Whatever it was, something changed for the better. And that really matters.

And so does my daughter’s experience of being given access to the specific therapy she needed to develop speech.

Neither child needed to be fixed. They needed adults to notice what might help them, give them opportunities to explore it, and support them as individuals.

That is what I hope we can offer every deaf child: not one prescribed route, but a genuine range of possibilities from which they can find their own way.

Because informed choice isn’t about choosing BSL or choosing speech. It’s about making sure families know there is a choice in the first place.

By Rebecca A Withey 

Rebecca A Withey is the Assistant Editor for The Limping Chicken. She is also a freelance writer, BSL consultant and creative artist based in the Midlands. Rebecca is a Deaf, bilingual BSL user.


Enjoying our eggs? Support The Limping Chicken:



The Limping Chicken is the world's most popular Deaf blog, and is edited by Deaf  writer and photographer Charlie Swinbourne.

Our posts represent the opinions of blog authors, they do not represent the site's views or those of the site's editor. Posting a blog does not imply agreement with a blog's content. Read our disclaimer here and read our privacy policy here.

Find out how to write for us by clicking here, and how to follow us by clicking here.

This site exists thanks to our supporters. Check them out below: